This show is floundering a bit -- they haven't figured out the new status quo. I don't care to see Serena being a bad girl again. It's not something that fits with her character as we've seen it over the last two years. She's fun-loving, but since coming back from school upstate she's always been the most sensible of the bunch. Not that they couldn't have played an arc where she slips into bad habits. But they haven't established it, they just stated it.
Blair is great when she's off-balance, but she dos better reacting to things in a big explosive way, not being small and mousy. And it's a mistake to have Dan be BMOC right away. He is the ultimate insider, it's true, but it's better if he has to work for it.
Actually, one thing I've noticed is that I'm much less forgiving with everything they get wrong about college life. I never went to a hoity toity private school on the Upper East Side, so I can at least pretend to suspend disbelief about all its excesses. But I did go to college, and it was a college with lots of people from different backgrounds, including some insanely rich kids, And none of them ever threw a sushi party. But if they **had** -- damn straight we'd all have been there instead of watching some documentary in the common room.
--Alex